Le Toiny
Set into the hills of the island's untouched southeast coast, a Relais & Châteaux property whose 22 villas each have a private infinity pool, overlooking a beach still considered a local surfers' secret.
Book on Booking.comQuiet time
November or February–March — the same Caribbean luxury setting with meaningfully lower rates and easier reservations than peak season.
Crowd hack
Avoid the island entirely during the last week of December — yacht traffic and villa rates hit their absolute yearly peak.
Insider tip
Take the hotel's coastal hiking trail in the early morning — Toiny Bay's currents keep it genuinely quiet even in high season.